Monday, November 16, 2026

‘No babies, no toddlers’: The Virginia island where land and people are disappearing

 

John Anglim/CNN




TANGIER ISLAND, Virginia — 

When Gil Pruitt was growing up on the shrinking island of Tangier, winters were much colder than today, with ice sometimes covering the bay. Children on the West Ridge, a slightly elevated filament of land on the island’s western side, would walk to school together in packs to make the cold easier to bear. Gil would wait until the kids who lived a bit farther down the road walked by and then rush out to shelter among them.

“As a smaller kid, you’d walk behind the tall kids, to let them block the wind, because the school was on the other end of the island,” recalled Pruitt, who traces his ancestry back to some of Tangier’s early settlers in the early 1800s.

In 1960, the year Pruitt was born, the Census counted 876 people living on Tangier, an isolated offshore island known for its devout religiosity and, more recently, its flooding, sinking land. In 2017, President Trump called the town’s mayor and promised that, contrary to scientific predictions, Tangier Island would be around for hundreds of years to come. But the vulnerable island has eroded substantially since the 1960s, according to federal maps, especially on the western side, where Pruitt grew up. And its population today is only around a third the size it was back then — with an apparent rapid decline of more than 100 people in the last 5 years alone, due to both deaths and migration away. 

 

There has been no big solution for this environmentally embattled town; things have not gotten better, and it has become apparent that the most urgent threat may not be from the shrinking coast, but from the dynamics of an already small and aging population that is not replacing itself. Residents attribute the population decline to a lack of jobs, itself triggered by stringent regulations on blue crabbing imposed by Virginia in the late 1990s and early 2000s. But regular flooding, and an ever-shrinking island, surely don’t help.

One early member of the growing Tangier diaspora is Pruitt himself. He left at age 18 to go to maritime school and, a few years later, purchased a home on the mainland. He now lives in Onancock, Virginia, a roughly 15-mile ferry ride away. “I knew it would give me better opportunities going and coming from work,” Gil Pruitt recalled.

“And I knew, I didn’t know it, but I predicted, that Tangier wasn’t going to stay the same.” 

Brett Thomas, captain of the Courtney Thomas mail boat, points towards Tangier Island in May 2026. On this trip, in addition to passengers, the boat carries packages from Amazon, groceries and flowers for prom at the island’s school.

Tangier residents leave Swain Memorial Methodist Church after Sunday morning service on May 3.


Tangier is a charming tangle of small houses connected by narrow roads traversed by golf carts and exceedingly few cars. Everyone stops to wave as you motor by. Houses and buildings line three “ridges,” strips of high ground connected by bridges. The harbor is a gauntlet of crab houses on stilts, although locals say most are now unused and some sit in obvious disrepair. A “Trump 2028” flag flies off one dock.

Just a little over a square mile in area, the tiny island came to broad national attention in 2017. That’s when the town’s mediagenic mayor for more than two decades, James “Ooker” Eskridge, received a call from President Trump, pledging his support. Trump had seen a prior CNN story on the island’s struggles with sea level rise, which also mentioned how popular Trump was with the people living here. 

 

Immediately, how you felt about Tangier got tightly wrapped up with how you felt about climate change. Eskridge, who acknowledges Tangier is eroding but has been skeptical about the role of sea level rise, promptly went on to debate Al Gore about climate change in a CNN town hall.

The truth is that climate change is a problem for Tangier — but it’s not the only problem. Population loss may be moving even faster than land loss. That said, coastal erosion and rising seas put the island at ever greater risk. The island’s ridges — the high ground, but still very low — are slowly sinking and converting into marshland, as the ocean gets ever higher relative to the town’s existing structures. This helps explain standing water seen on lawns even on calm days, and increasingly, high tides that make their way right up onto the island’s narrow roads, and swirl beneath the school.

“At its heart, it’s a low elevation island that is relatively flat, and water comes up and stays up,” said Matthew Kirwan, a coastal scientist at the Virginia Institute of Marine Science, who has studied the island’s elevation and land conversion. 

A cross reading “Christ is life” stands in a marsh. John Anglim/CNN


 The Pruitt surname is one of several strongly associated with the island. The western shore, where Gil Pruitt grew up, faces the widest and deepest stretch of open water before you reach mainland Virginia and, thus, gets the strongest waves. It was on the southwestern end of the island that Joshua Thomas, the “parson of the islands” who helped to bring Methodism to the still highly devout Tangier, convened large camp meetings in the early 1800s. One of Gil Pruitt’s ancestors was part of Thomas’s generation and later purchased land on the next island to the north, in an area that would be abandoned by the 1930s. 

 When the British arrived in 1814 and occupied Tangier, they built a fort on the far southwestern shore and used the island as their central base for launching attacks that included the burning of Washington, DC, and the failed assault on Baltimore that inspired the writing of “The Star-Spangled Banner.” The British also used the island to house and train freed slaves, some of whom were redeployed in raids on the young United States. But with the rapid erosion of the coastline, the location of their base, Fort Albion, is now below the waves, well offshore.

 In 1850, the U.S. Coast Survey, the predecessor of today’s National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, created the first reliable map of the island group that includes Tangier. It showed a western shoreline that stretched almost continually from southern Tangier Island itself up to northern Goose Island, linking much of the island chain together. Today, Goose is separated from the rest of the group by nearly a mile of water. 


 

In the late 1800s and early 1900s, Tangier’s population began to grow rapidly, peaking at over 1,100 in the 1930 Census. Ironically, this growth occurred even as the island’s land area shrank, as documented in 1905 and 1942 U.S. maps.

This was hardly unique to Tangier. Erosion led people to retreat from multiple occupied Chesapeake islands in the early 1900s. By the time of Gil Pruitt’s birth in 1960, nearly every Chesapeake island — at least those not connected to the mainland by bridges — had been abandoned. 

 

Growing up on Tangier was all about the future of being a waterman. As early as 7 or 8 years old, Gil recalled, he and other boys were busily preparing their first boats. They tended to be little skiffs, left over from their fathers, and perhaps also passed down through their older brothers first.

By the time you were a teenager, you’d get to work on the crabbing boats. Like his father and grandfather, Gil worked four years as a winter crabber, using a dredge to bring in the catch — an approach that would later be superseded by the more popular crab “potting” techniques of today. But both styles required a grueling lifestyle of waking up at 4 in the morning (and sometimes earlier) to head out onto the water for a day of work, and getting back in the afternoon, utterly exhausted.

After a long day on the water, Gil knew well that he should go straight to bed. But in the exuberance of youth, he often didn’t do it. Instead, he’d pull out his runabout, an open-air speedboat, and head back out on the water yet again with friends. “You’re a youngster, you know? So, we’d water ski, I mean, get in and water ski until we couldn’t stand it,” he said.

While Gil and his friends fished and partied, another Pruitt relation, Asbury Pruitt, was closely studying the coastline on the western shore. He had anchored an iron pipe in the nearby marshes and regularly measured the distance from there to the sea. And so he began to record large losses, over 10 feet per year and even worse in some eras. In 1978, Pruitt recorded a loss of 31 feet, a change so big it drew Washington Post coverage at the time. 

A home is reflected in a puddle. Standing water is a common sight around the island, caused by the rising water table and constant flooding. John Anglim/CNN

 

The measurements helped set in motion action of a sort that Tangier arguably has not seen since. In 1990, the Corps of Engineers erected a $4 million seawall, just over a mile long, along the western shore. It directly protected the island’s airport runway, but also Tangier more generally.

The wall stopped the erosion in its tracks, at least for the area that it covered

 

The problem is defending everywhere else. Much of the island could be submerged during a hurricane, although those have fortunately been rare in the Chesapeake region. But subsidence and sea level rise only add to the problem.

Indeed, Tangier’s current sinking and the very existence of the Chesapeake Bay are part of the same geophysical mega-phenomenon — a result of a period of warming beginning some 18,000 years ago that gradually melted a colossal ice sheet covering much of North America. Meltwater from this ice sheet and other global ice that melted during that period flowed into the ocean. The rising sea filled what had once been an enormous river valley, creating the bay and turning high points into islands like Tangier.

North of the Chesapeake, the Earth’s crust had been compressed by the weight of the ice, while the ice-free area around Tangier bulged upward. When the ice retreated, the previously crushed land rebounded — while the Mid-Atlantic began to sink, a process that continues today.

On top of that, more recent global warming has accelerated the pace of sea level rise. Subsidence and sea level rise, in combination, thus lead to a very fast rate of change. At nearby Norfolk, Virginia, seas are rising by nearly a quarter of an inch yearly, or a foot every 50 years. With most of Tangier only about 3 feet above sea level, you see the problem. 

 

Mayor Eskridge — the man Trump called up in 2017 — is well known for attributing the island’s challenges to erosion but not sea level rise. But like his fellow islanders, he’s very conscious of the dramatic change that has occurred, and has seen it in his own backyard, which is also on Tangier’s West Ridge.

“When I first moved over here on this property, I had a huge weeping willow tree in the front yard,” he said. “Poplar trees growing down both sides of the yard, and they won’t grow here anymore.” 

Mayor James Eskridge, right, gestures as his brother William Eskridge looks on. John Anglim/CNN

A ‘For Sale’ sign hangs in the window of a home. John Anglim/CNN

An abandoned row boat lies in a marsh next to the town's school. John Anglim/CNN

 Meanwhile, the town faces hard times. 

 

The state of Virginia recently labeled Tangier a “fiscally distressed” community, due to failure to pay a variety of debts and properly maintain its financial records. A study by the Berkley Group, a consulting firm working for the state, went deeper, finding the town had not had a financial audit since 2012 or a budget since 2018 (one was finally adopted in 2026). The report refers to “misappropriation” of funds from the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality for improving the crucial harborside fuel dock, and states that Tangier did not report properly to the Treasury Department on its receipt of coronavirus relief funding, among other fiscal issues.

“As best I can find, this town has been running in the red for many years,” said Normand St-Pierre, a retired professor of agricultural sciences at the Ohio State University who moved here because of his love of sailing, and currently serves on the Town Council. St-Pierre guesses at least $300,000 was “sucked out” of the town, although he hesitates to allege fraud, suggesting more simple mismanagement may explain what occurred. But with some 200 households, and a median family income a little over $35,000, the people of Tangier can’t afford to pay it back, he said.

“We were expecting some form of bailout or financial assistance, and nothing’s been offered yet,” he said.

Recently, Tangier has seen the closure of its only true grocery store, and there are fears too about the shrinking enrollment at its only school. 

 The grocery, Daley & Son, sat in one of the larger buildings on the island, with a dramatic rectangular façade far wider and taller than the interior of the store itself. A tourist plaque says multiple stores stood at this location for decades, but the cost to buy food on the mainland and transport it to the island made the business challenging, several locals said, and the declining population didn’t help. The store has been closed for around a year but is now listed for sale. Irene Lewin, a realtor with Lewin & Carr, Inc. who sells many properties on the island, said she believes it will be bought and re-opened. “I’ll have it sold, I’m quite sure it will be open by spring,” Lewin said. “It’ll be up and going.” 

Mostly-bare shelves are seen through the front window of the closed Daley & Son grocery store. John Anglim/CNN

Craig Bonniwell throws a line from the bow of the Courtney Thomas mail boat as it docks at Tangier Island’s harbor. John Anglim/CNN

 

Tangier used to have multiple grocery stores, Gil Pruitt remembered. His grandparents on each side operated two separate ones. Before the proliferation of golf-cart transportation, he recalled, the stores used to be handily placed along the paths the islanders walked between the three populated ridges.

Tangier still has a store that sells necessities and some groceries, right at the dock where the daily mail boat arrives. And groceries can be delivered by that boat, from Crisfield, Maryland, if island residents place an order at Food Lion. Nonetheless, residents acknowledged the loss of the grocery has been a major blow. 

 

“It’s sad, that grocery store has been there since way before I was born,” said Tangier vice-mayor Beth Thomas, who operates the dock store. “Every business we lose, it’s sad.”

The closure of a grocery is one thing. But there are also concerns about the Tangier Combined School, which serves grades K through 12. It sits several feet off the ground close to one of the canals that cut between Tangier’s islands, and water sneaks beneath it at even modest high tides.

Today, the school has just 34 students, according to Accomack County Public Schools, the local school district. Two grades have no children at all in them. For grades 6-12, some subjects, such as science, are being taught remotely via screens, with the instructor on the mainland. In a statement, Accomack County Public Schools praised the local school as a place with “an extraordinary sense of community, where the unique character of Tangier Island is woven into every student’s educational experience.” But the statement added that “given its small enrollment, (the school) is not adding additional staff at this time.” 

Claire Dise and Madi Pruitt look at their flower bouquets before heading to prom. John Anglim/CNN

 

On a Friday in May, the school held prom. It included anyone in eighth grade or higher, which helped fill out the affair. Still, fewer than 20 attended, some with dates from the mainland. Future proms are likely to be even smaller, as at present, there are no very young children on the island waiting to start school.

“No babies, no toddlers,” said Eskridge. “And I think that’s the first time since our early beginnings that we’ve had that.” 

 

When Gil Pruitt departed, the island still had more than 700 residents, according to the 1980 census. By 2020, the census formally counted only 436 people here, and that was before the COVID-19 pandemic triggered multiple fatalities among the elderly. More recent census figures and the views of residents put the number closer to 300 or even lower. According to US Census data, the median age of island residents has also been steadily rising over the last 20 years and is now estimated at more than 60, more than 20 years above the US median.

“The challenge is, what is life like, what happens, when you’ve got a lot of older people, and hardly any young people,” said David P. Baker, a demographer at Penn State University who examined the Tangier population data for this story. “All of our social institutions are based on growth, or at least, a somewhat stable population.” 


 A number of Tangier homes now stand abandoned; some are even being slowly overgrown by plants and vines. The state of the houses is a sore point. Some on Tangier were roused by a recent Facebook post in a group called “Abandoned in Virginia,” showing photos of some of the island homes that are in worse condition. Tangier residents objected that the island is not “abandoned” and plenty of other attractive and picturesque houses remain. 

 

“Only pictures of the rough looking places!” replied one poster. “Did you see all the beautiful homes and sites while you were here? Or our beach? Or our views?”

Still, some homes are being repaired and sold. “In the last year and a half, I have brought 15 new owners to the island,” said Lewin, the realtor, who lives on Tangier part of the time. She notes that many new owners are, like herself, part-time residents, perhaps using their island properties as second homes, something that population figures may not take into account. A number of Airbnb’s have also emerged on the island, signaling a possible shift to a more tourism-focused future, one with fewer full-time residents but many part-time ones and visitors. “Tourism is going to be what makes the place grow,” Lewin said.

The island remains undeniably quaint. The Virginia Department of Historic Resources has documented as much in several reports. The history is not just tied to physical structures or events but language itself. Living on an island for multiple centuries, the people here maintained a unique dialect, as the writer Earl Swift explains in his book on Tangier, Chesapeake Requiem. That includes the practice of talking “over the left,” or, in essence, saying the opposite of what is meant, but with emphasis that gives it away — at least to fellow islanders.

That doesn’t make Tangier any less threatened — it merely underscores how much there is to lose. 

Normand St-Pierre gestures while talking to CNN in his Tangier Island home in May. John Anglim/CNN

Tangier Island, barely visible along the horizon, is seen through an opening in the hull of the Courtney Thomas in May. John Anglim/CNN

Crab pots are stacked on a dock. John Anglim/CNN

 

On the mainland, Gil Pruitt keeps up with the challenges Tangier has recently faced. He has one brother who still lives here, and another who moved away like Gil himself did, then moved back to Tangier to work on the water later in life but recently passed away. He holds powerful memories of how it was.

But at 18, he left for the maritime school at Piney Point, Maryland. Before long he was working for Steuart Transportation, supplying heating fuels to Washington, DC, by ship. His maritime career eventually took him to the West Coast, through the Panama Canal, up the Mississippi and into many other US waters. Much of the time, he served as captain of a variety of tugboats as they helped ferry larger vessels into port. 

 

After 46 years working at sea, Pruitt retired last year to Onancock, just a short skip across the water from Tangier.

In his retirement, Gil met with CNN along with his Tangier-born cousin, Guy Pruitt. Guy joked that when the two of them get together, they start “speaking in tongues,” referring to Tangier’s strong accent and unique pronunciations.

“I lived over there at a unique time, growing up,” said Gil Pruitt. “I would not trade my youth for anything. It was a better time back then.”

On a Sunday morning in May, 25 mph winds from the northwest assailed the Tangier coast, driving waves that busily excavated the brick and cinderblock remnants of an old structure, possibly a house. An old cement cistern sat alongside the bricks, breaking the waves into columns of spray. 

 

Not far from the ruins sat the 1990 seawall, the rock embankment that protects some of Tangier. But just past it, the waves cut deeply into the beach, defining foot-high sand cliffs and wrapping around tree stumps that once would have been far inland.

Tangier is threatened by the sea on multiple sides, but this is one of the most exposed locations. The question persists: What could possibly be done to better defend this small but historic island?

The Chesapeake Bay Foundation has been trying to help residents formulate plans. But while they have won some initial funding to design a shoreline “adaptation” plan for Tangier, these protections remain in the design stage and require additional funding for permitting and implementation. “We need to get started now,” said Tom Ackerman, the group’s vice president for environmental education. “Every major storm, every nor’easter takes another chunk out of the shoreline. But … we believe that losing Tangier is not an option.” 

The town’s water tower stands high above a tidal marsh. John Anglim/CNN

Tarps hang from one of the island’s homes that have fallen into disrepair. John Anglim/CNN

 

One breakthrough comes in the form of a recent project by nearby Northampton County, in partnership with the town, to dump 32,000 cubic yards of dredge material from a coastal creek onto the eroding area of the beach south of the seawall. That’s a project that could start as soon as late this fall or in the winter. Many other US localities facing erosion use this type of beach renourishment as an option, but Tangier has largely not had that benefit until now.

Residents frequently complain that Maryland has invested much more in protecting nearby Smith Island and letting it maintain a vibrant community than Virginia has in Tangier. The remaining population on Smith is smaller and similarly elderly, but it has remained more stable. The median income there is also nearly three times that of Tangier

 

Cameron Evans, Tangier’s former vice-mayor and a photographer and ecotour guide on the island, believes the route to federal funding lies in highlighting the island’s natural resources and calling for their protection. “We’re one-third the size we were since 1850, but year after year, the birds continue to come back, to try nesting,” he says. “They want to stay here and we want to stay here.”

Still, unless something changes, the dominant story may sound like Gil Pruitt’s: A story not of homecoming, but of moving away. The Tangier diaspora is already well known on the eastern shore of Virginia and in coastal Maryland. There are Pruitts, as well as Crocketts and Parks (two other prevalent Tangier surnames), all over the region, especially in and around Onancock, Virginia and Crisfield, Maryland, both sites of ferry departures to Tangier.

On a Virginia peninsula, rather than a Virginia island, Guy and Gil Pruitt looked back over photos of their fathers on their boats and batted around the names of crabbing vessels and buy boats. As they talked, it became clear that physically leaving Tangier hardly meant leaving the island’s influence behind. They were still watermen. They were the export of the island’s two centuries of seafaring expertise, a body of knowledge that will continue to shape the country long after whatever comes next for Tangier itself. 

A child pilots a small boat through Tangier’s harbor past the island’s many crab houses. John Anglim/CNN

" Chris Mooney is a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist and a CNN Climate contributor. He is currently the Julia G. and Alfred G. Hill Chair of Excellence in Science, Technology, and Medical Writing at the University of Tennessee in Knoxville. "

Saturday, November 14, 2026

The cloud forest being abandoned by its clouds

The Children's Eternal Rainforest in Monteverde (Credit: Jocelyn Timperley/ BBC)




 

By 

Fog should constantly shroud this unique Costa Rican forest, but instead its spectacular hanging gardens are drying out. Jocelyn Timperley reports from Monteverde.

On the misty Tilarán Mountain Range above Monteverde in Costa Rica, a rare combination of circumstances has led to something special.  

A pocket of forest constantly shrouded in thick cloud supports an enormous variety of specialist plants and animals. For many of them, this is the only place on Earth they are found.

The ecological diversity of this cloud forest beggars belief. Some 400 bird species live here, from the spectacularly loud three-wattled bellbird to the long-tailed manakin, famed for its males' courtship dance. Sloths, black-handed spider monkeys, jaguars, pumas and Baird's tapirs roam below the thousands of tree species which droop with dense carpets of plants. Dozens of unique amphibians thrive in the moist climate, and so many insect species they have never even been counted.

 "These forests here will go, 'Yikes, we're caught with our pants down. We don't have any mist and fog' – Nalini Nadkarni

 

But all is not well in this cloud forest, or many of the other patches of tropical cloud forest scattered across the world. Because it's becoming increasingly clear that the clouds that bring these forests to life are beginning to drift away.

As the clouds lift, the forest world below is being transformed.

A misty haven

"When I first came to Costa Rica and had my first look at the cloud forest, I was like 'Oh my God', look at all these plants, look at all these epiphytes.'" 

Ecologist Nalini Nadkarni and I are walking through the Bosque Eterno de los Niños (Children's Eternal Rainforest), a swath of cloud forest in northwestern Costa Rica around the size of Baltimore made up of a mix of pristine forest and reforested areas.

 

What are cloud forests?

Cloud forests are a specialised type of rainforest almost constantly enveloped in mist and fog.

Most are found in high mountains in the tropics sitting relatively near the ocean. These form due to the steady easterly winds which carry evaporated ocean water upslope, where it cools off and condenses into small droplets of fog. 

Tropical cloud forests make up only 0.4% of the Earth's land surface, but support 15% of all birds, mammal, amphibians and tree fern species, half of them found only in cloud forests.

 

When she first visited Monteverde in 1980 Nadkarni quickly became obsessed with epiphytes – a term for the hundreds of plant species, from orchids and bromeliads to mosses, ferns and lichens. Epiphytes sprout from every visible surface in the cloud forest, never touching the ground and gaining all their water and nutrients from the fog. In the 1980s, she says, nobody really knew anything about their ecological roles.

The trees here literally creak under the weight of their epiphytes. Climb into the canopy, says Nadkarni, who is now a professor at the University of Utah, and you find horizontal branches covered with them like carpets.

Epiphytes have evolved many ways to capture the water and nutrients from cloud forests' constant mist. It's orchids, though, that are the most diverse epiphyte family in Monteverde, with some 450 species. "Sometimes we're sitting on branches that have literally $10,000-worth [£7,500] of orchids," says Nadkarni. "It's so amazing."

The vast majority of the non-woody biomass of Monteverde's cloud forest is made up of epiphytes, while their ability to absorb nutrient-dense mist means they have a disproportionately high importance for other species too. "They're actually augmenting the amount of nutrients and providing these inside the forest to circulate internally," says Nadkarni. 

 It's still not known exactly how many epiphytes species exist in these forests, nor what proportion of them are found nowhere else – one of the many areas of research now trying to catch up even as the warming planet begins to change this ecosystem.

Nalini Nadkarni examines a tree covered with epiphytes in the Bosque Eterno de los Niños in Monteverde (Credit: Jocelyn Timperley/ BBC)

So what happens if the clouds lift, and these plants stop having year-round mist to drink? Their world gets torn apart. "These forests here will go, 'Yikes, we're caught with our pants down. We don't have any mist and fog'," says Nadkarni.

Scientists call it the "lifting cloud base hypothesis": warming temperatures due to climate change mean the mist keeps rising upward until it misses the mountains altogether, changing how frequently the plants and animals are immersed in cloud.

"And it's already happening?" I ask Nadkarni.

 

"It's already happening. We're already seeing effects."

Lifting clouds

Researcher Alan Pounds, a scientist at the Monteverde Cloud Forest Preserve, first proposed this lifting cloud base hypothesis in the 1990s. "It's been shown in lots of different areas that it is happening," he tells me, from the Andes to East Africa. 

Scientists including Pounds have been collecting data on the moisture in Monteverde's cloud forest since the early 1970s. In 1999, he and two colleagues published a paper warning the number of dry days – measured as days when a standard rain gauge fills less than a 10th of a millimetre, used as an indicator of mist and cloud water – had drastically increased, and was increasingly coalescing into runs several days long. 

"If you look back at the '70s, it was rare to have more than 25 days of the entire year where we weren't recording precipitation," he says. Through the 1990s, it was 59. Between 2015 and 2023, his preliminary, unpublished analysis indicates an average of 119 rain-free days each year, he says. Since 2002, he has additionally been collecting long-term data on mist and cloud-water to help make sense of it all, he says. Final results are imminent.

 

"[A cloud forest] is a mountain immersed in clouds," he says. "Or it's supposed to be, that's part of the problem – a lot of that is changing."

There are several other concerns about climatic changes to this cloud forest. In the dry season, wet days appear to be getting wetter, and dry days drier. "So far we're not seeing a decline in total precipitation," says Pounds. "[But] we're seeing more and more contrast." The size of the cloud bank may also be shrinking, says Pounds, though notes this is unconfirmed.

Epiphytes blanket a tree in the Bosque Eterno de los Niños (Credit: Jocelyn Timperley/ BBC)

Warning bell

Because they appear near mountain tops, typically above 1,500m (4,900ft), cloud forests tend to be far smaller than lowland forests like the seasonal rainforest that makes up most of the Amazon and lacks these year-round, low-lying clouds. In Monteverde, you can drive for five minutes and find yourself in a completely different microclimate.

 

The mountaintop location also means species are often isolated, and thus endemic – native only to one (in this case, often very small) area. It makes them particularly susceptible to extinction. 

Monteverde has already been the site of the most famous impact of the changing climate on cloud forests: the disappearance of the famous golden toad in the late 1980s. Living in only a tiny area of the cloud forest, the golden toad stayed buried underground for most of the year, emerging every spring to mate.

"You'd see these bright orange male frogs jumping around looking for females," says Nadkarni.

In 1987, over 1,000 golden toad adults were seen mating. By 1989, only a single male was spotted. The next year none. The golden toad is now presumed extinct. The likely cause: a deadly mix of climate change, an invasive fungus and a strong El Niño year – a weather phenomenon that pushes up global temperatures – which produced an exceptionally dry season. Pounds' and others research has since documented huge losses of frogs and toads linked to climate change and the Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis fungus.

The extinction of Monteverde's golden toad was among the first anywhere to be linked to global warming (Credit: Alamy)

The loss of species like the golden toad is a sign the habitat is in flux. One way to view the impact of the changing climate on the cloud forest, says Pounds, is that "it's turning into a seasonal rainforest… more like the lowlands". 

The result, he says, is that lowland species are moving in.

Newcomers

Not all species are happy to live in cloud forests, says Pounds, but "there are advantages… if you can deal with the conditions", such as escaping competition and predation from the many different species in lowland tropical forests. 

Now, though, as Monteverde's clouds lift, temperatures rise and the forest dries out, these lowland species are being seen more and more. Keel-billed toucans – opportunistic predators of other birds' eggs and chicks – are increasingly nesting alongside resplendent quetzals, the emblematic species of Central American cloud forests, which is already threatened due to deforestation. Poisonous snakes like the terciopelo are arriving in Monteverde. Lowland bats, appear to be moving up, including the enormous spectral bat, which preys on quetzals.

 

As the climate changes and these species arrive, they may be displacing and disrupting current residents, causing chaos in the complex, finely tuned microecosystems of the cloud forest.

Each species here has "its space, its schedules and its friends", says Daniela Quesada Cruz, community programme coordinator at the non-profit Monteverde Institute. The 75 species of wild avocado tree in Monteverde, for example, all produce fruit at different times of the year – any change and their fruit could rot with no birds visiting to disperse it.

Climate impacts mean that "you basically lose" the more specialised flora and faunas of the higher elevations, says Pounds. "It's all happening very quickly and we didn't really have the resources to do the kinds of systematic sampling of everything that we should have. It's overwhelming."

The resplendent quetzal, the long-tailed manakin and the three-wattled bellbird are among the most emblematic species of Monteverde's cloud forest (Credit: Getty Images)

Monteverde's cloud forest is not the only one at risk. Across Mesoamerica, climate change and deforestation are driving cloud forest plant species uphill by an average 1.8-2.7m (5.9-8.9ft) per year. Worldwide, 2.4% of cloud forest cover was lost between 2001 and 2018 alone.

'Canaries in the coalmine'

After the disappearance of the golden toad and decline of other frog species in Monteverde, researchers began seeing other clues of climate impacts in the cloud forest, says Nadkarni – including on trees and plants.

Cloud-loving epiphytes in particular are the "canary in the coalmine" for climate impacts, says Sybil Gotsch, a forest ecologist at the University of Kentucky. "It's the first plant community that's going to be affected… because they don't have roots that go to the ground. As the atmosphere dries out, we're going to lose those epiphytes." 

In the immensely complex cloud forests, measuring the extent to which losses are already happening is hard. But studies transplanting epiphytes to trees at lower elevations and in greenhouses have shown they are very vulnerable to lower amounts of mist, and projected large future extinctions if climate change continues unchecked.

Climate change has come along fast and with so many species living here, most lack long-term studies which can give baselines for tracking changes. In 2016, Gotsch began a 10-year study to track epiphytes, only for it to be cut off by Covid-19 (she will publish a paper covering the first four years in 2027). 

 

On a windy January day, I accompany Gotsch and Nadkarni on a visit to a farm in the cloud forest ecosystem where they are trying to understand what might happen to other species in a cloud forest with fewer epiphytes, by experimentally stripping trees of them now. "We don't want to wait 50 years [to find this out]," says Nadkarni.

Without epiphytes holding them back, for example, trees might grow more, says Gotsch – not as positive as it sounds, since they could use up yet more water.

Sybil Gotsch and Costa Rican scientist Elenter Cubero Campos examine a strangler fig tree which they stripped of its epiphytes in 2022 (Credit: Jocelyn Timperley/ BBC)

They show me two pairs of strangler fig trees; in each case, one has been stripped of its dense mat of epiphytes, the other left as a control. They have eight other similar tree pairs dotted around Monteverde.

Now they are measuring everything they can think of which might change in an epiphyte-less tree: from the surrounding temperature, humidity and wind speed to sap flow, leaf appearance and use by wildlife.

 

Unknown losses

Countless other changes could be occurring here out of sight.

Pounds tells me of "painfully obvious" declines in insect numbers, judging simply by how many appear around lights at night. (Ecologists in the nearby region of Guanacaste have similarly noted a huge drop in insects, including in its cloud forest, which they attribute to climate change.) 

Debra Hamilton, co-director of the Costa Rican Conservation Foundation (CRCF) and a restoration researcher at the University of Vermont, is similarly concerned by her observations of the decline in insectivorous birds. "That, I believe, is the canary in the coal mine," she says.

Hamilton, Pounds and other researchers are now conducting insect sampling and bird surveys in Monteverde to compare numbers with past data. A current worry is the ongoing super El Niño. "This upcoming year is projected to be very dry," says Nadkarni. "The canopy is likely to be hit hard." Hamilton notes that this year October, usually the wettest month, has been astoundingly dry. "It is the first time that I know of a weather alert for drought conditions during a month when we get an enormous amount of rains," she says.

 

What is the ultimate fate of the cloud forest's ecology under continuing climate change? One result could be a novel ecosystem: the new self-organising mixes of native and non-native species created by human influence that are increasingly common around the world. 

Still, it's not at all clear which, if any, of the cloud forest specialists might survive, says Pounds. It's impossible to predict, he says, what this ecosystem will become.

Connecting habitats

Monteverde is something of a green trailblazer. The area is protected by a patchwork of national parks and private reserves set up in the 1970s and '80s conservation boom and Monteverdeños are largely well informed about sustainability and their environment.

Over half of the world's tree fern spcies live exclusively in cloud forests (Credit: Jocelyn Timperley/ BBC)

Decades of ecological tourism in Monteverde has supported conservation, says Quesada Cruz, encouraging locals to move from farming cattle to providing night walks, zip lines and canopy tours – keeping trees on their land in the process. But she believes tourism may be reaching a limit of sustainability. In some places that had been reforested, she says, developers have now cleared the forest and built new hotels.

Long term efforts are creating corridors to connect the cloud forest with areas outside reserves, much of it private land, helping to create space for species to move and migrate. The Monteverde Institute hands out some 10,000 native trees per year to locals – creating both animal corridors and windbreakers for farmers in the area's windy terrain. There's a push to plant native species in gardens.

Ensuring connected habitats, along with wider restoration and protecting forest from development, fire and cattle, are still essential to protecting the cloud forest, says Katy VanDusen, coordinator of local climate non-profit organisation CorClima. 

‘No babies, no toddlers’: The Virginia island where land and people are disappearing

  John Anglim/CNN By Chris Mooney | Photographs and video by John Anglim   TANGIER ISLAND, Virginia  —  When...